New York Mills Homes for Sale

New York Mills Homes for Sale

Welcome to New York Mills, Minnesota—a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Otter Tail County. Known for its rich history, vibrant community, and picturesque landscapes, this charming city offers the perfect blend of small-town charm and modern amenities. With a population of just over 1,200 residents, New York Mills is a close-knit community where neighbors become friends and every day feels like a warm embrace.

The city is surrounded by stunning natural beauty, with nearby lakes and parks that provide endless opportunities for outdoor adventures. Whether you enjoy fishing, hiking, or simply taking in the serene views, New York Mills is a paradise for nature lovers. The city also boasts a thriving arts scene, highlighted by the New York Mills Regional Cultural Center, which offers a variety of events and programs throughout the year.

For those looking to call New York Mills home, you’ll find a diverse range of homes for sale that cater to various lifestyles and budgets. From cozy single-family homes with charming yards to spacious properties perfect for families, there’s something for everyone. Each home reflects the warmth and character of the community, providing a welcoming atmosphere for new residents.

With its excellent schools, friendly atmosphere, and an abundance of recreational activities, New York Mills is not just a place to live; it’s a place to thrive. Explore the homes for sale today and discover why so many are choosing to make New York Mills their forever home. Embrace the charm, the community, and the endless possibilities that await you in this delightful Minnesota city!

Newest New York Mills Homes for Sale

$124,900
ACTIVE Status ⋅ 2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 7111621 MLS ⋅ 1,024 SqFt.
Affordable living in the heart of New York Mills! This charming 2-bedroom home features a functional layout with two comfortable bedrooms and a main floor full bathroom for added convenience. Ideally located near downtown shops, restaurants, parks, and schools, you'll enjoy easy access to everything New York Mills has to offer. With plenty of character and opportunity to add your own personal touches, this home is ready for its next chapter. Schedule your showing today!

109 Main Avenue S, New York Mills

Listing courtesy of Centennial Realty.

$489,900
ACTIVE Status ⋅ 5 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 7113231 MLS ⋅ 1,904 SqFt.
Enjoy the privacy of country living with this spacious 5-bedroom, 2-bath home located on 7 scenic acres. The upper level is set up well for comfortable living and entertaining, with the large open floor plan filled with natural light. The lower features a walk out basement as well as in floor heat and large family room. Outside, you'll find everything you need for work, hobbies, and storage with a heated 30' x 48' shop and a large 48' x 48' pole shed. A welcoming circle driveway adds convenience along with tons of concrete to add great curb appeal and flexibility. There will also be a new septic installed prior to closing or escrowed. Whether you're looking for room to grow, space for your toys, or simply a quiet place to call home, this property offers endless possibilities. Schedule your private showing today!

57890 425th Street, New York Mills

Listing courtesy of Hinkle Realty.

$230,000
ACTIVE Status ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 7111385 MLS ⋅ 2,400 SqFt.
Whether you're looking for the ultimate weekend retreat, the perfect man cave, or a stylish she shed, this newer shouse offers endless possibilities. Thoughtfully designed with a kitchen, bathroom, and comfortable living area, it's move-in ready while still providing room to make it your own. Situated on a spacious lot in a desirable subdivision just off beautiful Rush Lake, the property offers ample space to expand the existing building or construct additional storage to fit your needs. The property is already equipped with a private well and septic system, adding convenience and value for future improvements. For year-round comfort, in-floor heat cables have already been installed. Simply connect a boiler to complete the radiant heating system and enjoy a warm, cozy space during every season. Whether you're searching for a recreational getaway, a hobby shop, a future home base, or an investment with room to grow, this versatile property offers a rare opportunity in a sought-after lakes area location.

36835 478th Avenue, New York Mills

Listing courtesy of Jack Chivers Realty.

$538,200
ACTIVE Status ⋅ 3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 7101641 MLS ⋅ 2,632 SqFt.
Escape to the country with this beautiful home nestled on 10 scenic acres, where rustic charm meets comfortable living. When you step inside you are met with stunning woodwork, and warm character and details throughout. The spacious kitchen offers an abundance of cabinets and workspace and is open to the dining room and living room for seamless entertaining. The main floor features a private primary bedroom with an en-suite bath. With 3 bedrooms and 3 baths, there is plenty of space for family and guests. The bonus room in the lower level is great for gaming, office or crafts. The lower level walk out provides a family room, office, bath, sewing/craft room. Step outside and enjoy the peaceful setting with mature trees, colorful flower beds and a nostalgic barn that adds timeless country appeal. A massive 120x36 shed (4320 sq ft) provides ample space for equipment, recreational vehicles, workshop and storage. The wrap around deck provides a gorgeous view and shade during the warm summer nights. There is so much to take in at this property. Be prepared to be impressed!

51374 330th Street, New York Mills

Listing courtesy of Centennial Realty.

$220,000
ACTIVE Status ⋅ 3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 7090533 MLS ⋅ 1,182 SqFt.
Welcome to New York Mills! This beautifully updated 3-bedroom home is ready for you to move right in and call it your own. If you are looking for convenience, comfort, and charm, you couldn't find a better location. Key Features You'll Love: Prime Location: Situated just moments away from local schools, beautiful parks, and a vibrant downtown area. Turn-Key & Fresh: Newly remodeled and freshly painted throughout, making it the perfect match for your lifestyle. Sunlit Living Space: The inviting family room is flooded with bright, natural light—perfect for relaxing or entertaining. Elegant Kitchen: Completely remodeled and designed to be as functional as it is beautiful for all your cooking needs. Endless Potential Areas: The unfinished basement currently serves as a highly functional space for laundry, storage, and a wood shop. However, it offers a fantastic blank canvas with the potential to add an extra bedroom or design a second family living area to instantly build equity.

100 Walker Avenue N, New York Mills

Listing courtesy of eXp Realty.

$204,900
ACTIVE Status ⋅ 3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 7098452 MLS ⋅ 1,470 SqFt.
Welcome home to this charming 3 bedroom 2 bath property nestled on a beautiful wooded lot. Enjoy the perfect blend of privacy and convenience with schools, parks, shopping and everyday amenities just minutes away. The functional floor plan offers comfortable living spaces. spacious bedrooms and two baths to accommodate family and guests. Lower level also has a sauna! An attached one stall garage provides convenient parking and extra storage. Relax outdoors surrounded by mature trees, fire pit, and perennials, while still being close to everything you need. Affordable. convenient and comfortable! Schedule your showing today.

408 E Gilman Street, New York Mills

Listing courtesy of Centennial Realty.

$215,000
ACTIVE Status ⋅ 2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 7095558 MLS ⋅ 560 SqFt.
Fabulous find here right on beautiful Big Pine Lake. This charming cabin close to Perham features a 2-bedroom 1-bathroom seasonal cabin offering cozy comfort with a beautifully updated exterior and interior all with an open-concept layout. Recent upgrades include new siding, a newer roof, windows, and flooring. Enjoy Big Pine Lake views on the spacious wraparound composite deck. Boasting 500 feet of prime lakefront, it’s perfect for swimming and has exceptional fishing. As a member of the association, you'll enjoy a maintenance-free lakeside lifestyle. This move in ready property comes furnished with everything you need to start enjoying the lake, known for its fishing, recreational opportunities and its size. Whether you enjoy summer or winter fishing, swimming, or boating around the lake, this lake has it all for you and is close to downtown Perham. Just relax and unwind lake life starts here.

42877 Sunshine Villa Drive, New York Mills

Listing courtesy of Real Estate Results.

$190,900
ACTIVE Status ⋅ 3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 7095320 MLS ⋅ 1,344 SqFt.
3-bedroom, 2 Bath home in New York Mills with a large private backyard. Enjoy the perfect main-floor living space, conveniently providing a seamless layout with everything you need just steps away. The basement provides an additional living space and bathroom. The 3 stall garage had a fire last fall and is believed to be structurally sound.

106 Cornwell Avenue, New York Mills

Listing courtesy of Century 21 Atwood.

$450,000
ACTIVE Status ⋅ 4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 7094210 MLS ⋅ 1,350 SqFt.
Sprawling 10-Acre Retreat in New York Mills! This beautifully updated 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom home offers the perfect blend of country privacy and modern living. The heart of the home features a newly remodeled kitchen that flows seamlessly into the dining and family rooms—ideal for everything from casual weeknight dinners to formal family meals. Step out onto the expansive, newly updated back deck, which offers the perfect vantage point for grilling and entertaining friends while overlooking a private backyard teeming with local wildlife. Adding incredible value to this property is a second, mostly finished detached building. Brimming with potential, this versatile space is a blank canvas ready for your final touches—perfect for a home office, studio, guest quarters, or secondary living space. Don’t miss this rare acreage opportunity!

57582 398th Street, New York Mills

Listing courtesy of eXp Realty.

$484,900
ACTIVE Status ⋅ 2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 7055422 MLS ⋅ 1,900 SqFt.
Located in rural New York Mills and just minutes from Perham! Discover your dream home, one level living, nestled on 10 acres along a serene country road. This exceptional property boasts 2+ bedrooms, including a primary suite and 2 bathrooms. Features a heated 4 stall attached garage and a workshop area—perfect for hobbies or projects. Step inside to find the open floor plan highlighted by large windows, flooding the space with natural light. 9-foot ceilings and a stunning gas fireplace! The kitchen offers oak cabinetry, stainless steel appliances and a large walk-in pantry. The spacious primary suite is a true retreat, offering a luxurious walk-in closet and an oversized bathroom with a double sink. Start your mornings off with a cup of coffee under the inviting covered front porch. The expansive acreage is ideal for a hobby farm and offers a 30x30 horse barn with a hydrant already in place. The backyard overlooks an absolutely stunning creek bottom with an abundance of deer & turkey! This maintenance free exterior, turn-key home is ready for you to make it your own—don’t miss out on this incredible opportunity!

51692 385th Street, New York Mills

Listing courtesy of Trilogy Real Estate.

$383,500
ACTIVE Status ⋅ 4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 7033664 MLS ⋅ 3,136 SqFt.
RENOVATED COUNTRY HOME WITH WOODS & PASTURE! Discover the perfect blend of Privacy & Modern Comfort with this beautifully Renovated Country Home set on 5.46 Acres just 9 minutes from New York Mills. With 3.75 Acres of Mature Woods & Established Trails winding throughout, the property offers a peaceful, secluded setting ideal for exploring, relaxing, and enjoying the outdoors. The open Pasture area provides excellent potential for a Hobby Farm, complete with a Lean-To Shed already in place. Step inside to find a fully updated home offering 4 Beds, 2 Full Baths, and 3,136 SqFt across two levels. The Beautifully Remodeled Kitchen features All-New Appliances, Cabinetry, a Center Island, and a Walk-In Pantry, creating a functional and inviting space for everyday living & entertaining. The Main Level Owner’s Suite includes a Walk-In Closet, Private Balcony, and an adjacent Bonus Room that would make an excellent home office or flex space. Downstairs, the Full Finished Basement offers a spacious Family Room, 2 Bedrooms, Laundry Room, and a Storage Room with direct access to the attached 14x24 Tuck-Under Garage. Additional Renovation Highlights include All-New Flooring throughout, fully Remodeled Bedrooms & Bathrooms, and a Brand-New Septic installed in 2024. With Modern Updates, Functional Land, and Peaceful Rural Surroundings, this property offers an Ideal Setting to enjoy Country Living with Room to Grow!

51132 340th St, New York Mills

Listing courtesy of Jack Chivers Realty.

Start Your Search

The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity Program of the Regional Multiple Listing Service of Minnesota. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other this firm are marked with the Broker Reciprocity logo. Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. Property locations as displayed on any map are best approximations only and exact locations should be independently verified.

Listing data © 2026 Regional Multiple Listing Service of Minnesota. All rights reserved. By searching, you agree to the EULA.