New York Mills Homes under $250,000

Welcome to New York Mills, Minnesota—a charming small town nestled in the heart of Otter Tail County. Known for its picturesque landscapes, vibrant community spirit, and rich history, New York Mills offers residents an inviting place to call home. With its friendly atmosphere and strong sense of community, this quaint city is the perfect blend of rural charm and modern conveniences.

New York Mills is surrounded by stunning natural beauty, with numerous lakes and parks that provide ample opportunities for outdoor recreation. Whether you enjoy fishing, hiking, or simply soaking in the serene surroundings, you’ll find plenty to explore. The town is also home to a variety of local shops, restaurants, and cultural attractions, including the renowned New York Mills Regional Cultural Center, which showcases local art and hosts community events.

For those seeking affordable housing options, New York Mills is an ideal choice. The real estate market offers a range of homes priced under $250,000, making it accessible for first-time buyers, families, and retirees alike. These homes often feature charming designs, spacious yards, and proximity to schools and amenities, ensuring a comfortable lifestyle without breaking the bank.

Living in New York Mills means embracing a slower pace of life, where neighbors become friends and community events bring everyone together. If you're looking for a welcoming place to settle down, explore the homes available in New York Mills, and discover the perfect blend of affordability and quality living in this delightful Minnesota town.

Newest New York Mills Homes under $250,000

$250,000

ACTIVE Status ⋅ 3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 7151035 MLS ⋅ 1,232 SqFt.

Rural New York Mills: This 3 bedroom, 2 bath home is set on a beautiful 3.45 acre wooded lot. The 2001 home has a 26x27 attached garage and a 30x40 pole building with lean-to. Recent updates include newer forced air furnace with central A/C, Shingles, and water softener. Located just off County Hwy 67, 7 miles North of New York Mills or 12 miles from Perham. To enjoy even more space, the adjoining 5 acre lot that is currently in CRP is available to purchase.

53745 440th Street, New York Mills

Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker Preferred Part.

$180,000

ACTIVE Status ⋅ 3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 7142954 MLS ⋅ 1,393 SqFt.

Welcome Home Just Outside New York Mills, Minnesota Country charm meets everyday convenience in this inviting 3-bedroom, 1½-bath farm-style home. Set just outside of town, this property offers the perfect balance — close enough for easy access to local amenities, yet private enough to feel like a true escape from it all. The classic farmhouse character shines throughout, offering warmth and space for comfortable, relaxed living. Adding even more value, a barn on the property provides endless possibilities — perfect for a workshop, extra storage, or a dream woodworking space for hobbyists and craftsmen alike. Whether you're looking to slow down, spread out, or simply enjoy a little more space and privacy, this property offers a rare opportunity to have the best of both worlds. Country living starts here.

52473 County Highway 14, New York Mills

Listing courtesy of eXp Realty.

$220,000

ACTIVE Status ⋅ 3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 7093380 MLS ⋅ 1,354 SqFt.

Move In Ready! 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom home nestled in the heart of New York Mills! Ideally located just blocks from City Hall, the school, downtown businesses, restaurants, parks, and other local amenities, this property offers the convenience of in-town living while embracing the warmth and character of a classic home. Built in 1920, this well-maintained home blends timeless charm with valuable updates. A new furnace installed in 2026 provides efficient comfort during Minnesota winters, while the roof on the detached two-stall garage was replaced in 2023, offering added peace of mind. The low-maintenance vinyl siding and central air conditioning make everyday living even more enjoyable. Step inside to discover inviting living spaces filled with natural light and character. The cozy gas fireplace creates the perfect gathering place for family and friends, while the functional layout offers three comfortable bedrooms and up graded bathrooms. Outside, you’ll appreciate the spacious wood deck, ideal for grilling, entertaining, or relaxing after a long day. The detached two-stall garage provides excellent space for vehicles, tools, toys, and additional storage. Location is everything, and this home delivers. Enjoy being within walking distance of schools, shopping, dining, churches, community events, and everything that makes New York Mills such a wonderful place to call home.

118 Tousley Avenue N, New York Mills

Listing courtesy of Boll Realty.

Start Your Search

The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity Program of the Regional Multiple Listing Service of Minnesota. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other this firm are marked with the Broker Reciprocity logo. Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. Property locations as displayed on any map are best approximations only and exact locations should be independently verified.

Listing data © 2026 Regional Multiple Listing Service of Minnesota. All rights reserved. By searching, you agree to the EULA.