Priests Bay: Lake Minnetonka Real Estate™

Priest's Bay is a unique and desirable part of Lake Minnetonka, situated west of Cook's Bay and indented on its southeast side by Phelps Island. Covering 144 acres of water with approximately 2.10 miles of shoreline, this bay offers an exceptional setting for lakeside living. Named after J.D. Priest, a farmer who acquired land on the bay's north shore in 1876, Priest’s Bay has a rich history and a vibrant community. Its serene environment and proximity to local amenities make it highly appealing to homebuyers, boaters, and outdoor enthusiasts. Nearby cities such as Mound and Minnetrista provide convenient access to the bay, offering a blend of small-town charm and modern conveniences.  

Priest's Bay is known for its natural beauty, featuring mature trees, calm waters, and a tranquil atmosphere. With water depths ranging from 10 to 20 feet, it is ideal for recreational activities such as fishing, kayaking, paddleboarding, and boating. The peaceful surroundings offer a retreat from city life, making it an excellent choice for those seeking a quiet lakeside lifestyle.  

The bay is conveniently located near key roadways such as Westedge Boulevard and Hardscrabble Point Road, ensuring easy access to local amenities. Residents can enjoy nearby shopping, dining, and entertainment options in the towns of Mound and Minnetrista. Additionally, the bay is connected to several other notable areas of Lake Minnetonka. To the east lies Cook’s Bay, which offers expansive water views and direct access to additional recreational opportunities. To the west, Halsted’s Bay serves as the farthest western inlet of Lake Minnetonka, making it a popular area for boaters and anglers. Phelps Island, which borders Priest’s Bay to the southeast, is another sought-after location featuring scenic lakefront properties.  

Water Quality and Clarity  

Priest's Bay maintains good water quality, making it suitable for various aquatic activities. The water depth and clarity levels are well-maintained, allowing for an enjoyable swimming and fishing experience. Local environmental reports and homeowner observations indicate that the bay is consistently monitored to preserve its cleanliness. Occasional algae blooms and aquatic plant growth are natural occurrences in the area, but conservation efforts help to mitigate their impact on the water quality.  

Real Estate on Priest’s Bay – What to Expect  

Priest’s Bay offers a diverse selection of real estate, including luxury estates, modern lakefront homes, and historic cottages. Many properties in this area feature private docks, spacious lakefront patios, and wooded lots, providing both privacy and scenic views. The real estate market in this area tends to be competitive, with high demand and limited inventory, making it a valuable investment for those looking to secure a home on Lake Minnetonka.  

Schools and School District  

The area surrounding Priest’s Bay is served by the Westonka School District, which is known for its high academic standards and strong community involvement. Families residing in this area have access to well-regarded schools, including Hilltop Primary School, Grandview Middle School, and Mound Westonka High School. The district’s focus on academic excellence, small class sizes, and a wide range of extracurricular programs make it a popular choice for families looking to settle in the area.  

Buying or Selling on Priest’s Bay  

For those considering buying or selling a home on Priest’s Bay, now is an excellent time to explore the opportunities available in this sought-after area. Whether you’re looking for a quiet retreat, a lakefront estate, or a property with easy access to boating and recreation, Priest’s Bay offers something for everyone. Reach out today to learn more about available listings and how to maximize your property’s value in this desirable Lake Minnetonka location. 

Latest listings on Priest's Bay:

$4,335,000
CLOSED Status ⋅ 5 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ 7027075 MLS ⋅ 5,276 SqFt.
Please note: This property consists of 2 parcels. Parcel 1 is 5.2.9 Acres and Parcel 2 is .74 Acres. CAUTION! You won’t want to leave… Set at the end of a quiet cul-de-sac on Hardscrabble Point, this thoughtfully designed classic Craftsman-style home is carefully tucked into the topography of a rare private peninsula on Lake Minnetonka—offering 550 feet of shoreline, sweeping panoramic views of water and light, and an unmatched sense of privacy. As you arrive, you wind past a 5.3-acre nature preserve of protected woods and wetlands—creating a natural buffer from the outside world. The setting feels intentional, almost as if it quietly invites you to leave behind the weight of the day… holding it there until you’re ready to pick it back up again. Pulling into the drive, you may find yourself pausing—as you often do—caught off guard by the shift. The stillness. The light. The subtle rhythm of the water surrounding you. Whatever it is, it’s consistent… and it’s yours. You’re home. Inside, the residence is designed to capture and reflect the ever-changing moods of the lake. Sunlight dances across the interior, refracted off the water, creating a living, breathing atmosphere that evolves throughout the day. Nearly every room is intentionally oriented to maximize mile-long views across thousands of acres of open water. With five bedrooms and six bathrooms, the home blends refined craftsmanship with relaxed livability. A main-level owner’s suite, private elevator, and open-concept living spaces offer both comfort and function. The chef’s kitchen features Thermador appliances, Cambria surfaces, and a butler’s pantry—ideal for both everyday living and effortless entertaining. Seamless indoor-outdoor living extends to a screened porch with fireplace, lakeside terrace, gas fire table, and pergola. A rare boathouse adds character and opportunity—perfect for storage or the potential to create a one-of-a-kind lakeside retreat. Additional features include an oversized three-car garage with epoxy floors, Pella windows, Kohler in-wall fixtures, backup generator, and extensive professional landscaping. This is more than a property—it’s a place where time slows, perspective sharpens, and the connection to the water becomes part of everyday life. The presence to the water here is rare. Come Home To Vacation.

3500 Lythrum Way, Minnetrista

Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker Realty.

$2,300,000
CLOSED Status ⋅ 4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 7009702 MLS ⋅ 4,840 SqFt.
Set along the shores of Priest Bay, this exceptional lakefront residence captures panoramic water views through walls of expansive windows, creating a seamless indoor-outdoor connection with amazing natural light. The main level offers a refined, yet highly functional layout, highlighted by a modern living room with a new gas fireplace and sweeping lake vistas. The thoughtfully reimagined kitchen and dining area feature striking finishes, generous storage and countertop space, and high-quality appliances, perfect for both inspired cooking and effortless entertaining. A sunroom and private office complete the main level, each offering tranquil views from every angle. Upstairs, the primary suite is a true retreat, where mornings begin with sweeping lake views. The private spa-like bath features a double vanity, oversized jetted tub, walk-in shower, and an expansive closet with custom storage. Two additional bedrooms, a full bath, and a convenient upper-level laundry room provide comfort and functionality. The walkout lower level is designed for year-round enjoyment, whether returning from a day on the water or winter activities. With 10 ft soaring ceiling height, this level will wow you and includes a spacious family room with fireplace, a large wet bar and game room, welcoming guest bedroom and bath, dedicated fitness area, and ample storage. Outdoors, the expansive decks showcase the coveted south-facing views and a rare sandy beach, offering an extraordinary backdrop for lakefront living. Additional highlights include a heated driveway (sensor operated or on-demand), attached heated two-car garage, detached three-car garage for all the toys, whole-house generator, and whole house water purification system. Simply put, this is lake living without compromise.

6001 Ridgewood Road, Mound

Listing courtesy of Fazendin REALTORS.

$2,873,181
CLOSED Status ⋅ 5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 6815291 MLS ⋅ 6,134 SqFt.
Discover timeless craftsmanship & modern luxury in this stunning custom-built Lake Minnetonka home featuring 95 feet of premier lakeshore and sweeping panoramic views. Designed for entertaining & everyday living, this home offers both formal & informal spaces that flow effortlessly throughout. At the heart of the home, a chef’s dream kitchen features professional-grade appliances, a butler’s pantry with an additional oven & oversized dishwasher, and a separate wet bar perfect for hosting gatherings large or small. The home’s rich character shines through in details like 150-year-old wide-plank white pine flooring/ fireplace mantle, and impeccable details & millwork. The spacious primary suite is a true retreat, offering serene lake views, a spa-like bathroom, and a massive walk-in closet with a secret room. Four additional bedrooms and a flex/amusement room provide comfort and flexibility for family and guests. You’ll love the convenient laundry on the upper level with additional laundry in the lower level. The partially finished lower level (with 10ft ceilings) is an entertainer’s paradise, boasting a cozy pub complete w/gas fireplace, a full wet bar, and an impressive 900-bottle wine room. A large laundry room is also located on this level, perfect for storing lake towels and suits. The large unfinished area offers endless potential - create an amusement room, fitness space, golf simulator, guest bedroom, or anything you envision. Plumbed for another wet bar and ensuite bathroom. With its thoughtful design, one-of-a-kind finishes, and breathtaking lakeshore setting, this home perfectly embodies the best of Lake Minnetonka living. Dock and jet ski lift included in sale.

3120 Highland Boulevard, Mound

Listing courtesy of Fazendin REALTORS.

Start Your Search

The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity Program of the Regional Multiple Listing Service of Minnesota. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other this firm are marked with the Broker Reciprocity logo. Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. Property locations as displayed on any map are best approximations only and exact locations should be independently verified.

Listing data © 2026 Regional Multiple Listing Service of Minnesota. All rights reserved. By searching, you agree to the EULA.